Skip to main content
Disability DiscoursesWays of understanding disability, mapped

How to read this map

A model of the models of disability

The field already talks about “models of disability”: medical, social, charity, rights-based and dozens more. This map is a model too. It sets those models side by side so you can see what each one assumes, how they relate, and how place and law shape them. This page explains what a model is and what the map’s design is saying.

The argument in brief. A model is a tool for thinking, and every tool carries assumptions. Each model of disability puts disability somewhere: in the body, in relationships, in institutions, in society and culture. The map is built to make those placements visible, so they can be compared and questioned.

1What a model is

Most models in science and scholarship are representations: they stand for a selected part or aspect of the world (Frigg & Hartmann, 2025). A model never shows everything. It keeps some features, leaves others out, and arranges what it keeps so that relationships become easier to see. Simplifying is how a model does its job.

Four ideas from the philosophy of science help explain what a model does:

  • Models are mediators. Morgan and Morrison (1999) argue that models sit between theory and the world and work partly on their own. They are built from bits of theory, bits of evidence and the modeller’s own choices, and people learn by working with them. This is the closest fit for this map: it is neither one theory nor raw data, but a working tool between the two.
  • A model represents because someone uses it for a purpose. Giere (2004) holds that nothing is a model on its own: a person uses it to represent part of the world, for a particular aim. A model is judged by how well it serves that aim, not by whether it is a perfect copy.
  • Models work like metaphors. Black (1962) showed how models and metaphors organise thought: seeing one thing in terms of another highlights some features and hides others. “Disability is a disease” and “disability is a barrier built by society” are both metaphors in this sense, and each one steers what people notice and what they do next.
  • Models differ from theories and frameworks. A theory is an abstract account of how things relate. A conceptual framework is a researcher’s argument for why a study matters and how it will be done (Varpio et al., 2020). A model is usually narrower and more concrete than a theory, and it is often the thing a framework draws on.

Model or conceptual framework?

The words overlap, and it helps to be open about that. Jabareen (2009) defines a conceptual framework as “a network, or ‘a plane,’ of interlinked concepts” that aims at understanding rather than prediction, and he keeps the word model for work built on variables and factors. By that definition, this map is close to a conceptual framework: it links concepts and invites interpretation. By Morgan and Morrison’s definition, it is a model: a built object that mediates between theories and the world. This page uses model, because the field already speaks of “models of disability” and the map is a model of those models.

Whetten (1989) gives a practical test for any theoretical contribution: it should say what factors matter, how they relate, why (the reasoning behind the relationships), and who, where and when it applies. The map answers each one. The ideas are the what. The threads between them are the how. Each idea’s assumptions and metaphors are the why. Time and the lenses are the who, where and when.

2Models of disability are models

Models of disability are a clear case of models as thinking tools. Smart (2009) argues that these models carry real power: they shape how disability is defined, who is seen as responsible, what professionals do, how laws and funding are written, how the public responds, and how disabled people understand themselves. Retief and Letšosa (2018) survey nine of the most widely used models by comparing their basic features, which is itself a kind of model-building.

The quickest way to see a model’s assumptions is to finish four sentences the way that model would. Every idea on the map has these four sentences. Here are five of them:

ModelDisability is…A disabled person is…The response is…The professional is…
Morala sign, punishment, test, or blessinga bearer of spiritual meaning, sin, or graceprayer, penance, healing, or acceptancea priest, healer, or moral authority
Medicala disease, defect, or deviation from the norma patientdiagnosis, treatment, rehabilitation, or curean expert clinician who diagnoses and prescribes
Socialoppression produced by barriersa citizen excluded by societyremoving physical, attitudinal, and structural barriersan ally who follows disabled people’s lead
Human rightsa human rights issuea rights-holder with inherent dignityrealizing rights through law and policya duty-bearer
Affirmationa valued part of identity and lifea person with a positive, non-tragic identitycelebration, pride, and self-definitionan affirming partner

Read across a row and you can see one model’s whole logic. Read down a column and you can see how differently the models answer the same question. Each model also places disability at a different level: the medical model in the body and mind, the social model in society and culture, the human rights model across institutions and society. The map’s cards show this as a set of five shaded rings, from body and mind out to population and planet.

3The map as a meta-model

Every design choice on the map is a claim. Placing two ideas close together says they are related, and putting one in the distance says it is older. Naming those claims lets you use the map well and argue with it where you disagree.

How the 3D map is laid out Four columns run left to right: individual, interaction, society and politics, and identity, culture and critique. Nested frames recede into the distance to show time, with antiquity farthest away and today nearest. Small shapes stand for ideas, coloured and shaped by stance. Antiquity19001975Today IndividualInteractionSociety & politicsIdentity, culture& critique Where disability is located: from the body outward to society and culture Depthis time
Figure 1. The layout of the 3D map, simplified. Across: where each idea locates disability. Depth: when it took shape. Colour and shape: its stance toward disability. Original figure © 2026 S. Sheppard, ThreadSpace.
On the mapWhat it claimsWhat it can hide
Left to rightIdeas can be ordered by where they locate disability: individual, interaction, society and politics, then identity, culture and critique.Many ideas span several levels. The biopsychosocial model touches four of the five rings, but it can only sit in one place.
DepthIdeas have a history. Older ones sit far away and newer ones come forward.Distance can look like “outdated.” Older models are still at work today: the medical model still shapes most funding and diagnosis. Some dates are approximate and are marked as such.
Colour and shapeEach idea takes a stance toward disability: deficit, neutral, affirming, or critical.Stance is a judgment made by the mapmaker, and one idea can be used in more than one spirit.
SizeLarger stars have more connections on this map.Size reflects the links recorded here. It is not a measure of importance or influence.
ThreadsIdeas relate in named ways: one builds on, critiques, contrasts with, bridges or co-opts language from another. The map records 125 such links.Most links (83) are a general “related to”; the sharper labels are fewer and are the most interpretive.
Gold markersLaws, court cases and other landmark events connect ideas to what happened in the world.The events chosen lean toward places the lenses cover.
Kind of ideaEach entry is a model, theory, classification, field, paradigm, knowledge system, practice or narrative (Varpio et al., 2020).Kinds are a reading; Deaf studies, for example, is both a cultural model and a field of study.

A model is judged by its purpose (Giere, 2004). This map’s purpose is to help teachers, coaches, students, researchers and advocates compare ideas about disability, see what each assumes, and trace how they connect, especially where they meet schools and sport. It is not a ranking, and it does not say which model is right.

4Lenses and jurisdiction

Models do not float free of place. The same idea plays out differently depending on who holds the power to act on it. The lenses let you light up the ideas and events that matter in one place or one perspective.

Nested lenses Four nested ovals: international and UN on the outside, then regional, then national, then provincial, territorial or state on the inside. A band labelled perspectives runs across all four, for Indigenous perspectives, the Global South and sport. A note asks who holds education and health. International (UN) Regional National Provincial,territorial or state CRPD, treaty bodies Europe, Asia and the Pacific Canada, United States Perspectives that cross every level: Indigenous, Global South, sport Division of powers Who holds education? Who holds health? The answer decides where a model lands.
Figure 2. Lenses nest from international law down to provinces and states, while perspective lenses cut across every level. Original figure © 2026 S. Sheppard, ThreadSpace.

Nested layers. At the top sits international law, above all the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. Below it are regional bodies, then national governments, then provinces, territories and states. In the 3D map, the Canada lens opens into each province and territory.

Division of powers. In a federal country, the constitution decides which level of government holds education and health. In Canada, education belongs to the provinces under section 93 of the Constitution Act, 1867. That is why inclusive education can look very different in Alberta, Ontario and Nunavut, even under the same Charter and the same Convention. The World Atlas records who holds education and health in every country, along with each country’s constitution and its Convention status.

Perspective lenses. Some lenses are not jurisdictions at all. Indigenous perspectives, the Global South and sport cut across every level, because they carry their own ways of knowing, histories and institutions.

5Where the words come from

Models are built from words, and words carry history. The Words glossary takes 77 terms apart, from handicap and crip to inclusion and person-first versus identity-first language. For each one it records where the word came from, who shaped it, how its meaning shifted, what it assumes, and where the debate stands now.

Take normal. It began as the Latin for a carpenter’s square, and only around 1840, alongside the new science of statistics, did it come to mean “usual” or “average”. Within a few decades the average had become an ideal, and difference had become a problem to fix. Every model that measures people against a norm inherits that history, whether or not it says so.

Every idea on the map also records where its own name came from. The rehabilitation model took shape after the two World Wars to return injured veterans and workers to productive life, and it brings that goal into a school or a gym. “Neurodiversity” was coined by sociologist Judy Singer in 1998 and developed by autistic self-advocates, and it brings a very different history. Knowing where a word comes from helps you notice what it is quietly asking you to assume.

Some entries have unclear or contested origins. Those are marked “under review” while the sources are checked, rather than given a confident date the evidence does not support.

6How the map was built

Jabareen (2009) sets out eight phases for building a conceptual framework from many disciplines. The map followed the same path:

  1. Map the sources. Disability studies, rehabilitation, education, sport, law, philosophy, Indigenous scholarship and UN documents, along with practice in schools and sport.
  2. Read and sort. Sources sorted by discipline and by how central they are within it.
  3. Name the concepts. Each recurring way of understanding disability became an entry, including ones that contradict each other. The map now holds 88.
  4. Take each concept apart. Every entry records its focus, origin, where it locates disability, its four metaphor sentences, key concepts, authors and references. This matches Jabareen’s table of name, description, role and sources.
  5. Group them. The entries fall into six families: individual and deficit-oriented; interactional; social, political and rights-based; identity, cultural and critical; classification and measurement; and where models meet schools and sport.
  6. Synthesize. The families became the map’s space: position, depth in time, stance, and the named threads between ideas. This went through many rounds of revision.
  7. Check it with others. Citations are checked against their sources, review passes have corrected individual entries, and unclear entries stay marked until they are resolved. Comments from scholars and practitioners are the next step.
  8. Keep rethinking. The map changes as new work appears. Recent changes added place-based lenses, an Indigenous perspectives lens, and a label for what kind of idea each entry is.

Jabareen notes the main limit of this method: different researchers may build different frameworks from the same literature. The map is one careful reading. It is not the only possible one, and that is why its claims are written out on this page.

7Using the map

Teachers and coaches

  • Pick a policy or a practice you use. Which model does it assume?
  • Compare the “response is” sentence across three models, then ask which one your classroom or team acts on.
  • Turn on your province’s lens to see the laws that frame your work.

Researchers

  • Use the kinds of idea to tell a theory apart from a model or a field before building a theoretical framework.
  • Follow the “critiques” and “builds on” threads to trace a debate.
  • Check a model’s origin before citing it as if it were settled.

Advocates and students

  • Find the model behind a news story or a funding rule.
  • Compare two countries on the World Atlas to see how division of powers changes what is possible.
  • Ask what the map leaves out, and send it in.

References