Skip to main content
Disability DiscoursesWays of understanding disability, mapped

A Thread Map of Disability Discourses

88 ideas about disability, from models and theories to classifications, fields of study and practices, laid out like a transit map. Each coloured thread is a family of related ideas; where threads cross, an idea belongs to both. Select any station to read about it, and see Theory, model or framework? for how each kind is used in research, or how to read this map.

Guided tours

Threads

    Stance (click to toggle)

    • Interchange (on 2+ threads)
    • Highlighted by you
    • Entry under review
    How to read the map

    Zones run left to right by where each model locates disability: in the individual, in the interaction between person and environment, in society and politics, and in identity, culture, and critique.

    Above the dashed line sit discourses on responding to disability (services, law, schools, and sport). Below it sit discourses on interpreting disability (what disability is).

    Click stations on and off to highlight them. Highlighted models glow, their threads and connections light up, and the rest of the map fades back, so you can compare several models at once. The tray above the map lists your highlights. Threads toggle on and off in the Threads list: switch on one or more to show only those, or choose "Show all." Stances in the key toggle on and off the same way.

    Compare and share. Choose "Compare models" to line up as many models as you like side by side: click stations on the map, type names into the comparison panel, or tick them in the index. "Copy link" saves the exact view, highlights and threads included, so you can share it with students or colleagues.

    Guided tours walk through a sequence of models one step at a time, tracing a gold path across the map.

    Threads are families of related models. Each thread runs through its models like a transit line through its stations. Select a thread in the list to follow it on its own.

    Stations are coloured by stance, taken from each entry. Interchanges, drawn as larger white stations, sit on two or more threads, which is where the families overlap. Grey stations stand on their own.

    Kinds of idea. Each card and entry says what kind of idea it is: a theory, a model, a classification, a field of study, a paradigm or movement, a knowledge system, a practice, or a narrative. See Theory, model or framework? below.

    The Measurement frameworks line along the bottom holds the classification frameworks in historical order, since they apply across every zone.

    The zone guide under the map summarizes what each zone casts disability, the response, the disabled person, and the professional as.

    Theory, model or framework?

    The map itself is a model of these models. How to read this map explains what a model is, what the layout and colours claim, and how the map was built.

    Most entries are called "models", because that is the name the literature gives them, but they are different kinds of idea. Following Varpio, Paradis, Uijtdehaage and Young (2020):

    A theory is a set of logically related ideas that explains how things connect. Theories can describe, explain, emancipate, disrupt or predict, and they work at different scales: grand theories (for example, crip theory or the capabilities approach), middle-range theories (DisCrit, Thomas's social-relational model, social role valorization) and micro-level theories (psycho-emotional disablism).

    A theoretical framework is what a researcher builds to put one or more theories to work in a study: defining the concepts, linking them, and showing how they shape the question, the data and the analysis. The map supplies the theories; the framework is yours to build.

    A conceptual framework is the case for why a study should be done: what is already known, the gap, and the methodology chosen to address it.

    How studies use theory. Deductive research starts from a theory and tests hypotheses drawn from it. Interpretive research uses theory in one of three ways: building theory from the data (as in grounded theory), letting a theory inform the whole study, or choosing a theory during analysis. Deciding which, early, and saying so, keeps a study coherent.

    The other kinds. Models are simplified working pictures, usually from practice, policy or activism; Mike Oliver and Vic Finkelstein both called the social model a heuristic device rather than a theory (Barnes & Mercer, 2004). Classifications such as the ICF describe and measure. Fields of study, such as critical disability studies and Mad studies, hold many theories. Paradigms and movements, such as disability justice, set values and principles. Knowledge systems belong to peoples and Nations. Practices, such as inclusive education, are usually what research studies. Narratives, such as the supercrip story, are what research critiques.

    Barnes, C., & Mercer, G. (Eds.). (2004). Implementing the social model of disability: Theory and research. The Disability Press.
    Varpio, L., Paradis, E., Uijtdehaage, S., & Young, M. (2020). The distinctions between theory, theoretical framework, and conceptual framework. Academic Medicine, 95(7), 989–994. https://doi.org/10.1097/ACM.0000000000003075